The Citizens Budget Commission’s Charles Brecher presented a report this morning on “Benchmarking Efficiency for the Metropolitan Transportation Authority’s Services.” Brecher and his staff compared the MTA’s operating efficiency across subways, buses, and commuter-rail systems across those of other nine major cities in the U.S.

Brecher’s conclusion:

[T]he MTA’s bus system is “inefficient in comparison to other large U.S. bus systems and comprise a major portion of MTA operating expenses. Similarly, the two commuter railroads are relatively inefficient, with the LIRR often ranking as the worst in the nation.

The buses won Brecher’s “bottom of this pack” distinction, quoted above. On labor productivity in the MTA’s bus system, for example, the MTA comes in 10th out of 10 in terms of how many hours of service customers get for every hour that an MTA employee works, 21 percent worse than the median.

Metro North and Long Island Rail Road rank low, too, largely because of “exceptionally high maintenance costs,” Brecher notes. The ranks are particularly dismal when one considers that the LIRR’s trains are the newest in the nation.

The MTA does much better on subways, with the lowest cost per hour of service after Chicago. However, the drawback to this comparison — as discussed at today’s breakfast — is that it likely would be better to compare the MTA’s subway system to global networks, not to American ones. The MTA’s system is four times as big as runner-up Chicago, for example, in operating costs.

As one audience member noted, New York’s subway system only has two peers in the world, London and Tokyo. Without comparisons to these and other large European and Asian systems, we can’t know if the MTA is wringing all of the benefits from potential economies of scale in the subways.


You may also like

MTA’s Casino Funding Takes Voters For A Ride

As the Legislature prepares to authorize new downstate casinos, some voters who supported the amendment are discovering they came up snake-eyes. Read More

MTA: Overtime down, take our word for it

Every year for over a decade, the Empire Center has submitted Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) requests to the Metropolitan Transportation Authority for the payrolls of MTA corporate subsidiaries. And in almost every one o Read More

Policing the MTA’s overtime police

The Metropolitan Transportation Authority has assigned its own police force to monitor attendance and overtime use by Long Island Railroad employees, the Daily News reports. Read More

A check on transparency

The MTA has now paid the Empire Center's expenses for a successful lawsuit compelling timely release of the agency's payroll data. Read More

Buses, trains and six-figure pay

Employees of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) make a good buck, and six-figure cash compensation in 2013 was by no means limited to the white-collar higher-ups, according to 2013 payroll records posted at SeeThroughNY today. Read More

Transparency, not

Last week, at a Manhattan news conference that was also “live-streamed” on Governor Andrew Cuomo’s website, the chief executive officer of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) and the president of Local 100 of the Transit Workers Union signed a memorandum of understanding (MOU) reflecting a tentative contract deal that will shape the MTA’s labor compensation costs for years to come. Read More

Paterson, Gelinas mix it up on transit

Nicole Gelinas — Manhattan Institute senior fellow, City Journal contributing editor and frequent blogger here — wrote a tough column in the New York Post yesterday, criticizing Governor Cuomo’s nomination of former Governor David Paterson for appointment to an open seat on the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) board. The choice, Nicole said, was tantamount to “business-as-usual New York" ... Read More

The MTA tax ruling: calling the GOP’s bluff?

Republican pols in New York’s downstate suburbs loudly celebrated last week’scourt ruling tossing out a payroll tax enacted by the Legislature in 2009 to subsidize mass transit in the 12-county Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) region. Read More