2606308483_4a28fe7dd6-7950294We never thought it would be easy to collect and update the data we need to populate our transparency website SeeThroughNY. In fact, we make it a point to keep our expectations tempered because we know government agencies are, no doubt, juggling a lot of things.

But, at the same time, we need to weigh the rights of New York taxpayers to have access to how their tax dollars are spent.

And we carefully considered those two things while waiting for the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) to comply with a Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) request we filed for payroll files. Our decision to sue the MTA wasn’t taken lightly, coming only after we had given the agency every opportunity afforded by FOIL — and more — to provide the data we had requested.

When the MTA didn’t comply, and it was overwhelmingly clear that this pattern, now six years in the making, wouldn’t end, we filed our Article 78 proceeding to compel action.

Our case was so strong that the MTA agreed to settle out of court, agreeing to provide the data and to pay the Empire Center’s attorney fees and costs associated with the filing of the lawsuit. It was less about the money and more about holding the agency accountable for providing information within the timelines prescribed by FOIL. After all, if this was happening to us it surely was happening to others who might not have the resources to risk thousands of dollars taking the agency to court.


The $2,680 check the MTA wrote to the Empire Center doesn’t sound like much in the context of the MTA’s $16.5 billion budget—but it nonetheless translates into nearly 1,000 basic transit fares. We’re confident the agency has learned a lesson here; even more important, an unmistakable signal has been sent to other New York government agencies.

About the Author

Tim Hoefer

Tim Hoefer is president & CEO of the Empire Center for Public Policy.

Read more by Tim Hoefer

You may also like

MTA’s Casino Funding Takes Voters For A Ride

As the Legislature prepares to authorize new downstate casinos, some voters who supported the amendment are discovering they came up snake-eyes. Read More

Another Hochul To-Do: Timely Financial Reporting

The state will spend a record $212 billion in the current 2022 Fiscal Year, under the budget its elected leaders adopted in April. Read More

Health Research Inc. Turns Over its Payroll Records Despite Claiming To Be Exempt from FOIL

The full payroll records of more than 2,400 de facto state employees are available to the public for the first time after being released by Health Research Inc. Read More

MTA: Overtime down, take our word for it

Every year for over a decade, the Empire Center has submitted Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) requests to the Metropolitan Transportation Authority for the payrolls of MTA corporate subsidiaries. And in almost every one o Read More

Policing the MTA’s overtime police

The Metropolitan Transportation Authority has assigned its own police force to monitor attendance and overtime use by Long Island Railroad employees, the Daily News reports. Read More

Budget pours more into slush fund

The new state budget will fund a 35 percent expansion of a murky $1.1 billion pork-barrel slush fund controlled by Governor Andrew Cuomo and state lawmakers. Read More

Local govs score with better websites

In 2014, the Empire Center created guidelines for what information local governments and school districts should make available on their websites—and found that most of the state's 500 largest municipalities and districts were not meeting that standard. Read More

Save the cookies

New York’s Legislature has been exempt from many provisions of the state Freedom of Information Law since FOIL was first enacted in 1974. The Assembly and Senate ultimately decide how much legislative information to make public. This makes about as much sense as putting Cookie Monster in charge of security at the Chips Ahoy factory. As a result, a lot of information on legislative matters ranging from individual employee timesheets to a billion-dollar slush fund has been concealed from taxpayers. But if Governor Cuomo has his way, that could soon change. Read More