Manhattan beep and mayoral candidate Scott Stringer says he has a “bold plan” for the MTA. But beneath the fancy talk of an “infrastructure bank” and “dedicated revenue,” it’s the same old plan: more taxes.

headshot_nov2011_vertical-8444961
MBP Scott Stringer

That’s a shame, because without real change, the MTA won’t be able to pay for the other good ideas Stringer has.

At a speech before the Association for a Better New York (ABNY), Stringer said that the state-run Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA)’s “fundamental problem is a lack of reliable funding streams.”

To fix this problem, Stringer proposes a “New York City Transit Trust” to follow Rahm Emanuel’s “visionary” example in Chicago in “leverag[ing] private dollars.” At least some of these private dollars, he says, would come from union pension funds.

But a trust is worthless unless it has money. Moreover, investors, whether they’re from the private sector or the public sector (which gets its investment dollars from the private people who buy municipal bonds, anyway, making the distinction odd), want to get repaid. And how do you repay investors? With money.

So Stringer’s leveraged trust relies on “a dedicated revenue stream.” To wit, he would take the $400 million that the MTA gets every year from the downstate mortgage-recording tax and put that money toward capital spending rather than operating spending. Stringer’s reasoning is that the mortgage-record tax is volatile and unsuitable for operating spending.

Moving $400 million from the MTA’s operating budget creates a new $400 million deficit. Not to worry. Stringer has a plan for that: a new tax, one that would raise at least $725 million a year (which experts say is more than $400 million).

He says that New York should restore the commuter tax, or failing that, think about congestion pricing (now called “fair plan” pricing) or a new tax on the number of miles people drive.

Such a new tax would create a challenge for the MTA. For the past three years, it has been collecting $1.8 billion annually in what it calls “new state taxes and fees,” including $1.2 billion from the new tax on downstate payrolls. Perhaps the MTA could call Stringer’s tax a “new new tax”?

All joking aside, though, the problem with Stringer’s plan is that he doesn’t address the cost side. Yes, yes, he says the MTA should cut out waste, and he criticizes the Fulton Street transit extravaganza (a pet of Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver). But he doesn’t acknowledge the fact that the MTA will spend $2.6 billion in health and pension costs this year, nor does he acknowledge that the MTA could shave out $307 million in annual savings in three years’ time with a solid labor contract.

Moreover, Stringer’s rationale for moving the mortgage-recording tax is a red herring. The problem with the tax is not volatility. The problem is that at the height of the property bubble, it brought in $1.5 billion — something that was never supposed to happen. The MTA could have put the extra funds aside, but instead spent them on ballooning labor and debt costs.

Stringer is missing an opportunity here — and that’s a shame. For some of his actual transit ideas are not so bad.

He wants more dedicated bus lanes. That’s a fiscally solid idea. By bringing some riders above ground, such lanes reduce pressure on the subways without the MTA having to build more subways. Dedicated bus lanes also take space away from cars — showing that Stringer is brave enough to face off against one special interest, drivers (one that’s obviously not as strong as the city’s labor unions).

In the same vein, Stringer suggests a light-rail line (basically a bus on a track) for 42nd Street, another good idea, although a dedicated bus lane there might do the same trick for cheaper, at least for a while.

But blueprints are meaningless without $$$, and Stringer is proving to be another knee-jerk pol whose first solution — before considering anything else — is yet another tax on New Yorkers.

You may also like

MTA: Overtime down, take our word for it

Every year for over a decade, the Empire Center has submitted Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) requests to the Metropolitan Transportation Authority for the payrolls of MTA corporate subsidiaries. And in almost every one o Read More

Policing the MTA’s overtime police

The Metropolitan Transportation Authority has assigned its own police force to monitor attendance and overtime use by Long Island Railroad employees, the Daily News reports. Read More

A check on transparency

The MTA has now paid the Empire Center's expenses for a successful lawsuit compelling timely release of the agency's payroll data. Read More

Buses, trains and six-figure pay

Employees of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) make a good buck, and six-figure cash compensation in 2013 was by no means limited to the white-collar higher-ups, according to 2013 payroll records posted at SeeThroughNY today. Read More

Transparency, not

Last week, at a Manhattan news conference that was also “live-streamed” on Governor Andrew Cuomo’s website, the chief executive officer of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) and the president of Local 100 of the Transit Workers Union signed a memorandum of understanding (MOU) reflecting a tentative contract deal that will shape the MTA’s labor compensation costs for years to come. Read More

Paterson, Gelinas mix it up on transit

Nicole Gelinas — Manhattan Institute senior fellow, City Journal contributing editor and frequent blogger here — wrote a tough column in the New York Post yesterday, criticizing Governor Cuomo’s nomination of former Governor David Paterson for appointment to an open seat on the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) board. The choice, Nicole said, was tantamount to “business-as-usual New York" ... Read More

The MTA tax ruling: calling the GOP’s bluff?

Republican pols in New York’s downstate suburbs loudly celebrated last week’scourt ruling tossing out a payroll tax enacted by the Legislature in 2009 to subsidize mass transit in the 12-county Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) region. Read More

There goes the MTA bailout – CORRECTION

AUTHOR’S NOTE: PLEASE SEE BELOW FOR IMPORTANT CORRECTIONS TO THIS POST IN BOLD.In May, after months of turmoil, Albany agreed to a new package of taxes for the state-run Metropolitan Transportation Authorit Read More

Empire Center Logo Enjoying our work? Sign up for email alerts on our latest news and research.
Together, we can make New York a better place to live and work!