As expected, the state Senate voted today to place on November’s statewide ballot a constitutional amendment that would greatly expand the Legislature’s budgeting power at the Governor’s expense. If enacted, it would represent the most sweeping shift of constitutional authority in New York State since the enactment of the current Executive Budget provisions (Article 4 and Article 7 of the Constitution) more than 75 years ago.

We’ve had a lot to say about this already — here, for instance — and will be saying more in the future.

For the time being, it’s sufficient to observe that the amendment (A2) would:

* give legislators a strong new incentive to stall budget action until they pass the start of a new fiscal year, and
* effectively outlaw late budgets solely by dint of creating an automatic and permanent contingency budget, subject to changes the Legislature alone could originate (with added spending still subject to the Governor’s veto).

Assuming the Legislature also moves the start of the state fiscal year from April 1 to May 1, as proposed in a separate implementing bill approved by both houses but vetoed Tuesday by Governor George Pataki, the first budget proposed by the next governor would be alive for just 89 days. The entire Executive Budget would then be automatically shoved into the trash if either house of the Legislature doesn’t like it — which, based on past experience, is highly likely.

Oh, and legislators will no longer forfeit pay for failing to pass a budget on time — because, under this amendment, inaction on the Executive Budget would be tantamount to “final action” as far as the Constitution is concerned.

About the Author

Tim Hoefer

Tim Hoefer is president & CEO of the Empire Center for Public Policy.

Read more by Tim Hoefer

You may also like

Keep the Change 

As the pandemic subsides and Cuomo’s emergency orders expire, the state should take some of what he has done by fiat and keep the change.  Read More

Post-Pandemic, New York should “Keep the Change”

Albany, NY — Many of the executive orders signed during the COVID-19 pandemic should be codified into law, specifically those that address health care services, occupational licensing and government transparency, according to a new Empi Read More

Medicaid Migraine: Retaking Control of New York’s Surging Health-Care Costs

This Gov. Hugh L. Carey Policy Forum forum will draw attention to the Medicaid spending surge, trace its underlying causes, and point the way to constructive solutions. Read More

Capitol Pressroom: Gov. Hugh L. Carey Policy Forum

In recent memory, New York’s budget negotiations typically end with the good, the bad, and the big ugly. Is it time to change the way the state budget is negotiated? We recapped this morning’s event on the topic with EJ McMahon, Founder and Research Director of the Empire Center, and former Assemblyman Richard Brodsky. Read More

Empire Center Introduces Gov. Hugh L. Carey Policy Forum

The Empire Center for Public Policy will honor the late former Governor Hugh L. Carey with a policy forum series devoted to issues in New York State government. Read More

New York’s Budget Process: Time for a Rebalance?

Is it time to consider potential changes to New York’s state budget-making rules? At its inaugural Governor Hugh L. Carey Policy Forum in Albany on May 30, the Empire Center will assemble leading experts with hands-on experience in the budget process to explore answers to those questions. Read More

Cuomo’s Buffalo Billion was beyond corrupt

The overarching scandal here wasn’t bid-rigging or the pay-to-play pattern in the developers’ contributions to the governor’s reelection campaign. At the root was a simply awful public policy — corporate welfare on steroids — that neither Cuomo nor most of his critics have definitively renounced, even now. Read More

Inside the Legal Battle for Transparency

This new timeline traces five legal battles the Empire Center has fought since 2009 against public agencies that refuse to allow taxpayers to see where their money is going. Read More