pension-bomb-150x150-6806953The Empire State’s largest public pension plan still has not fully recovered from the financial crisis and Great Recession of 2008-09, a new report from the state comptroller’s office confirms.

The New York State and Local Retirement System (NYSLRS), which covers all state, county and municipal workers outside New York City, ended its 2016 fiscal year with a long-term funding shortfall (i.e., liabilities minus assets) of $12.4 billion to $19.5 billion, depending on which actuarial method is used to calculate the difference between pension assets and liabilities. Those numbers translate into funded ratios of 93.9 percent or 90.6 percent, respectively.

You’ll find these numbers on page 5 of NYSLRS’ latest Annual Report to the Comptroller on Actuarial Assumptions. But don’t bother looking for them in today’s press release from NYSLRS’ sole trustee, Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli, who unsurprisingly focuses solely on the next projected change in taxpayer-funded contribution rates. For the first time in four years, average taxpayer-funded contribution rates won’t be going down. Rather, as DiNapoli put it, they “will stay virtually the same in Fiscal Year 2017-18 compared to Fiscal Year 2016-17.”

The average contribution rate for the Employees’ Retirement System (ERS) will decrease from 15.5 percent of payroll to 15.3 percent of payroll. The average contribution rate for the Police and Fire Retirement System (PFRS) will increase to 24.4 percent from 24.3 percent of payroll.

“After three years of rate reductions, pension contribution rates will remain stable for our participating employers in the near-term,” DiNapoli said. “While the financial markets have been volatile, our pension fund remains one of the strongest and best funded in the country, allowing New York’s public workforce to retire with the knowledge that their pensions are secure.”

The actuarial report shows that, in fiscal 2016, NYSLRS’ long-term liability for pension benefits grew by at least $6.5 billion, topping $200 billion for the first time. Figured on the same basis, the pension fund’s long-term liability 15 years ago was less than half as large, at $98 billion.

Keep in mind that those numbers are based on permissive government accounting standards, which allow all public pension funds to “discount” (i.e., reducing, in current terms) the dollar value of future liabilities based on assumed investment earnings, which for NYSLRS are pegged at 7 percent a year. Corporate pensions must use much lower discount rates reflecting the actual expected return on low-risk government bonds, which in turn requires them to contribute more to pensions as a percentage of employee salaries. If NYSLRS liabilities were valued in line with standards favored by most private-sector actuaries and economists, the funded ratio would be well below 90 percent.

If pension liabilities are growing steadily, how can DiNapoli hold employer contribution rates roughly level after a year of no investment gains?  The actuarial report chalks it up mainly to two factors: First, because the system (like most government counterparts) “smooths” the impact of its annual investment returns over a five-year period, it is still benefitting from a 13 percent investment gain in 2014. Second, newly hired employees assigned to Tier 6, the pension plan enacted under Governor Cuomo four years ago, have somewhat less expensive retirement plans.

Another story buried in the actuarial data: It turns out that (as shown on page 4 of the report) police and firefighter salary increases last year actually averaged 7.2 percent, compared to the 4.7 percent expected under actuarial assumptions. The pension plan’s salary assumption for all other employers was much closer to the mark, with an actual gain of 3.7 percent compared to expected raises of 3.8 percent.

And so, says the report:

In a nutshell, the impact of the FY 2014 investment performance and the new entrant gains due to the growth in the number of less expensive tier 6 members more than offset the FY 2016 investment performance. Actual ERS salary increases for full timers was very near the expected value, so ERS nets a small reduction. PFRS salary increases for full timers was greater than expected, so PFRS did not net a small reduction.

The longer-term story is sobering. As shown in this chart from the comptroller’s office, NYSLRS contribution rates as a percentage of payroll remain significantly higher than they were from the late 1980s until the Great Recession.  Think of this as the new norm—or the return of an old norm. The late 1980s also marks the beginning of the period in which the vast majority of current state and local officials first took office—which perhaps helps to explain why so many of them were (or still are) unprepared to deal with a world in which generous, guaranteed retirement benefits for public employees actually cost something.

Again, keep in mind that if these pensions were valued and funded on a more conservative basis, reflecting the risk-free nature of the constitutionally guaranteed promise made to public employees, contributions would be considerably higher. And, in fact, should be, to reduce the risk exposure of the public in general.

Bottom line: even as a somewhat cheaper tier of employees joins the workforce, New York State and its local governments will never again receive a pension contribution bill in low digits for ERS members, or low teens at worst for cops and firefighters. Indeed, given the extent to which stock prices are now propped up by near-zero interest rates—which can’t last forever—and given the real possibility of a recession sooner rather than later in the next few years, the contribution rates are more likely to rise again before the decade is over.

About the Author

E.J. McMahon

Edmund J. McMahon is a senior fellow at the Empire Center.

Read more by E.J. McMahon

You may also like

Cuomo’s $1.7B Medicaid mulligan

This year's state budget came with a hidden asterisk: In the final throes of his negotiations with legislative leaders, Governor Cuomo quietly postponed a month's worth of Medicaid payments from the last week of March to the first week of April – shifting $1.7 billion in spending from one fiscal year to the next. Read More

DiNapoli blocks the union exit

State officials are still working overtime to shield government unions from the impact of the U.S. Supreme Court decision in Janus v. AFSCME. This week, Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli’s office has issued new guidelines effectively giving the unions the first say on efforts by employees to opt out of union dues payments. Read More

NYSTRS bill to drop again

The New York State Teachers' Retirement System (NYSTRS) will reduce its pension contribution rates for a third consecutive year in 2017-18, even though the pension fund's investment returns came in well below its target rate in fiscal 2016. Read More

DiNapoli’s “slight gains” in context

New York's largest public pension fund earned 2 percent in its first fiscal quarter—which isn't necessarily good or bad news for taxpayers. Read More

NYC pension costs shooting up

Taxpayer-funded pension contributions in New York City will need to increase by a total of $732 million between fiscal years 2018 and 2020 due to the pension funds' paltry investment earnings in the recently concluded 2016 fiscal year, City Comptroller Scott Stringer has just disclosed. Read More

Medicaid audit misses big picture

State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli accentuates the negative in a new audit of the state’s Medicaid managed care program, faulting two participating insurers for “wasting millions of state Medicaid dollars.” But he omits two important pieces of context. Read More

Some solid ideas from DiNapoli

Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli just issued a set of fiscal reform proposals designed to address the continuing lack of accountability and transparency in key areas of New York's budget. While by no means representing a fiscal panacea, they are solid ideas, deserving of broad public and legislative support. Read More

Skelos pension could exceed $95k

Following his conviction on federal corruption charges, former Senator Dean Skelos apparently will qualify for a public pension of up to $95,590 a year. Read More


Sign up to receive updates about Empire Center research, news and events in your email.


Empire Center for Public Policy
30 South Pearl St.
Suite 1210
Albany, NY 12207

Phone: 518-434-3100
Fax: 518-434-3130


The Empire Center is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit think tank located in Albany, New York. Our mission is to make New York a better place to live and work by promoting public policy reforms grounded in free-market principles, personal responsibility, and the ideals of effective and accountable government.