As if it wasn’t bad enough that New York imposes some of the nation’s highest property taxes, the Empire State’s patchwork system of local property tax administration is rated the nation’s worst in a new scorecard compiled by a corporate-sponsored tax organization.

house-of-cash3-300x300-9354429The Council on State Taxation (COST) assigned New York an overall grade of “F” based on an analysis of three criteria described as follows:

  • A fair property tax system must have standardized filing, remittance and appeal procedures throughout the state;
  • The appeal process for property tax disputes must be before an independent tribunal, in a de novo hearing, without a pay-to-play requirement for disputed property taxes; and
  • The property tax burden must be balanced and uniform and not shifted onto business taxpayers.

COST gave New York a grade of F on the first characteristic, C- on the second  and D on the third. It assigned points to each grade — with higher point totals corresponding to lower grades. That yielded this overall top 5 and bottom five ranking:


COST focuses on taxes from a business perspective, and its scorecard research was completed before the adoption of New York’s new 2 percent cap on annual growth in property tax levies (outside New York City, that is). However, while the cap is certainly fair, applying to the levy on all properties, it is also likely to draw more attention to the administrative shortcomings of local property tax administration as it affects homeowners as well as businesses.

Even in places where all the taxing authorities (schools, towns and counties) hold their limits, some property owners will find their own tax bills rising much faster. The culprit, in many cases, will be the same inconsistent assessment practices cited in the COST report.

Massachusetts, whose Proposition 2.5 cap was the model for New York’s, ranked 25th with an overall grade of C- on the COST scorecard.


About the Author

E.J. McMahon

Edmund J. McMahon is Empire Center's founder and a senior fellow.

Read more by E.J. McMahon

You may also like

Don’t Mess with the Tax Cap

The property tax cap has an extraordinary record of restraining tax hikes without unduly straining education budgets. Read More

Report Reveals Albany’s Balanced Budget a Gimmick

Extending the budget window reveals large, yawning budget gaps growing from nearly $8 billion in 2026 to nearly $20 billion by the end of the decade. Read More

School budgets sail under cap

Yesterday’s school budget votes proved once again New York’s school districts aren’t having much difficulty staying under—or overriding—the property tax cap. Read More

A SALT cap surprise (so far)

The newly enacted federal income law provision limiting state and local tax (SALT) deductions "is likely to substantially decrease home values" in New York, Connecticut, Maryland and New Jersey. That's a key claim of the lawsuit filed by the four states against the Trump administration today with the goal of having the $10,000 SALT deduction cap declared unconstitutional. Read More

The Senate GOP’s mixed bag on taxes

State Senate Republicans today issued a "Blueprint for a Stronger New York" that combines a few solid big-picture tax reduction priorities with more of the wasteful "tax relief" gimmickry that's become a standard feature of the Senate GOP tax policy agenda in recent years. Read More

Cuomo’s Yuletide veto gifts

Governor Andrew Cuomo is ending the year on a strong pro-taxpayer note, vetoing union-backed legislation that would have blocked the Nassau County Interim Finance Authority from imposing pay freezes to balance the county budget. Read More

Tax Cap = Budget OKs

The tax cap effect was on full display in yesterday’s school budget voting. School budgets were approved at a record-high rate of 99.3 percent, adding to evidence that districts can live within a property tax cap set at either 2 percent or the prior year’s average rate of inflation, whichever is less. Read More

Parsing a NY Medicaid takeover

A mandated state takeover of local Medicaid costs, added to the House GOP health bill by U.S. Reps. Chris Collins and John Faso, promises relief for property taxpayers across New York. However, some counties stand to save more than others. Read More