psc-150x150-2713629Governor Andrew Cuomo’s regulatory attack on National Grid’s Long Island gas moratorium threatens to have broader negative financial effects on all of the state’s investor-owned utilities—with implications for the overall business climate as well.

Three days after Cuomo made public a letter threatening to strip National Grid’s natural gas franchises downstate, Moody’s Investor Service announced a “ratings downgrade review” of Brooklyn Union Gas Company and KeySpan Gas East Corporation, both owned by National Grid:

The rating action reflects social and governance risks around customer relations and broader stakeholder engagement…

Moody’s incorporates a view that one of the core competencies for all US regulated utility companies is the ability to maintain a supportive and constructive relationship with their respective regulators.  [Brooklyn Union’s and KeySpan’s] current situation in New York evidences, however, that the relationship and communication channels between the utility and key stakeholders are currently extremely strained. Moody’s views political intervention as a material credit negative, especially when the intervention emanates from a governor’s or attorney general’s office. [emphasis added]

In a separate research note (behind the rating agency’s paywall, and first reported by POLITICO), Moody’s said Cuomo’s “heightened willingness” to “intervene in utility regulation” through the state Public Service Commission (PSC) was “credit negative for all New York investor-owned utilities.”

Franchises are the providence of the PSC, a five-member appointed panel, but the governor has taken to saying franchises are not “God-given.” Besides National Grid, Cuomo has threatened to strip three other companies’ franchises during 2018 alone: Charter (cable), American Water (water) and Con Ed (electricity).

The governor, in fact, has treated the ostensibly independent PSC as if it were an agency answerable directly to him.

Under Cuomo, the commission has all but perfected a technique under which the governor publicly reacts to an an issue dominating news coverage, such as a power outage, issues a directive to the PSC, its chair, or its subordinate Department of Public Service (DPS) to “investigate.” The PSC often then issues an “order to show cause,” which commences an investigative and penalty process. That quickly morphs into closed-door negotiations—where the governor’s office is free to exercise influence, utilities are eager to reach a deal, and the public is left in the dark. Charter, for instance, was in secret talks with the PSC for nearly a year after its franchise was threatened.

As Moody’s observed:

“The threat to revoke a utility’s license represents a weakening of the consistency and predictability of New York’s utility regulatory environment…While there have been instances of negative political rhetoric regarding utility franchise licenses in the past, they have not resulted in a formal letter which appears to bypass the regulatory process.”

Cuomo’s approach constitutes a major departure from more than a century of PSC protocol and sparked criticism from a contingent of retired DPS employees, including the former chief counsel. The governor has meanwhile used the PSC’s powers to levy surcharges on utility bills to collect (and spend) money for items such as a multi-billion bailout for Exelon and a slew of other smaller energy programs—all without involving the Legislature.

But beyond driving up energy costs with new hidden taxes, the Moody’s note is a salient warning that Cuomo’s mishandling of the PSC presents added risks to the state’s business climate.

For one thing, any downgrade in bond ratings will make it more expensive for utilities to finance capital projects—and those higher borrowing costs will translate into higher rates and delayed or cancelled investments.

That’s an especially big problem for people in more rural areas waiting for natural gas or internet service expansions. These buildouts wouldn’t just be more expensive. In the current climate, businesses need to think twice about locking up capital in New York and increasing their exposure to Cuomo’s erratic regulatory whims.

And an example of that came just yesterday: American Water, a private company that provides water service on Long Island, announced Wednesday it was selling off its New York assets. The business came under fire in recent years for making miscalculations in filings to the PSC, and then for hiking rates for high-volume customers. The decision to cash out suggests the company didn’t see New York as a good place in which to invest—despite the fact that, for utilities, the customer base is essentially permanent.

Finally, Cuomo’s rhetoric risks fueling calls for government entities to provide utility services.

As if government’s track record operating New York City’s subways and public housing—not to mention Long Island’s electricity service—hadn’t put people through enough.

You may also like

New York’s Medicaid Spiral Is Worse Than Hochul Admitted

Although Governor Hochul said last week that the current trajectory of Medicaid spending is "not sustainable," the upward trend is even steeper than she and her budget director have acknowledged. Read More

NY’s Road To Electric School Buses Gets Bumpy

New York in 2022 told school districts they’d be barred from purchasing gasoline- or diesel-powered buses after 2027, and instead have to buy electric buses at more than double the upfront cost. “The purchase of new electric buses will help grow the market,” officials later pledged, “which will in turn help reduce prices.” Unfortunately for taxpayers, those reductions aren’t materializing—because state officials put the prices, and future increases, on cruise control. Read More

Hochul Shows a Jarring Lack of Direction on Health Care

Financing and regulating health care delivery is one of the biggest responsibilities of state government, yet Governor Hochul had remarkably little to say on that topic in her State of the State speech on Tuesday. Read More

Hochul’s Pushing Affordability. It Would Cost A Lot.

Governor Hochul is hammering an “affordability” theme in the leadup to Tuesday's 2025 State of the State address. But her campaign, dubbed "Money In Your Pockets," has so far featured little that would reduce the cost of providing, and therefore buying, goods or services in New York. Instead, the biggest announced and expected elements reflect Albany's waning interest in growing the state economy—and a greater appetite to redistribute what it produces. Read More

Unions Reprogram NYS To Do Less With More

Governor Hochul on Saturday signed an innocuous-sounding bill to “regulate the use of automated decision-making systems and artificial intelligence techniques by state agencies.” But the “Legislative Oversight of Automated Decision-making in Government,” or LOADinG Act, wasn’t about protecting New York from self-aware computers trying to wipe out humanity. Instead, it was an early Christmas present for the state's public employee unions—and a lump of coal for New Yorkers hoping for more efficient state government. Read More

Former Utility Regulator Warns State Lawmakers They’re On the Naughty List

A legislative hearing into spending by the state’s sprawling energy agency featured a surprise guest who offered sober warnings about Albany’s energy policy. Read More

New York’s Public Employee Shortage Is Over

Public employee unions complained loudly when New York's state government workforce shrank during the coronavirus pandemic, using that decrease as pretext to press Governor Hochul and state lawmakers for more hiring and costly giveaways to benefit their members. But the latest data show nearly every state agency has more employees than it did a year ago, and that by at least one key measure, the state workforce is larger than it was before COVID. Read More

Upstate Insurance Customers Pay the Price for Medicare’s Hospital Rate Hike

A billion-dollar Medicare windfall for upstate hospitals has turned into a crisis for upstate health insurers that's threatening to disrupt coverage for millions of New Yorkers. The Read More